Twice is still 1st tho 
Twice is still 1st tho
Not on this list, but yes on others.
Not on this list, but yes on others.
On the most important list which is money earned from albums
First week sales have never been their strength even when they were the top selling gg per album. Can they compete with 4th gen is a good question but this isn't the metric to use for it
Itzy did well in the first week, so is not a JYP problem, RV and BP did well, so is not a 3rd gen problem.
I think they will sell a good number, but it would be hard to get top 3.
They have never great numbers on Hanteo. RV is doing better than Twice but FOL still selling more.
On the most important list which is money earned from albums
True, for over all revenues, they are still the #1 G.G.
At least in terms of music, if we add revenues due to sponsorships, Black Pink may come on top with all those sponsorships, BP are social media legends, YG is a genius on exploiting that revenue stream.
Display More
I think we will get a good idea in a few days on which way Twice is heading.
Twice not coming back in almost a year has made yall a little too brave 
Out with the old, in with the new.
I feel bad for IVE, they seem to be getting ignored by these type of threads.
Don’t worry they will do better than your faves 
BTW, for people that think Red Velvet is irrelevant.
They may not be the top group, but they are a top group. They belong in any top 5 - top 10 Girl group conversation.
The better question is, do first week sales even matter for TWICE when they are gonna outsell every GG on this list except for 1 or 2 at best?
4th gen groups can have this record cause they have nothing else to brag about
Twice not coming back in almost a year has made yall a little too brave
9 months, they almost sold a million last time (perhaps they did if we can get numbers from all over the world).
As someone pointed out above, they are slow starters, but they sell well.
Hopefully they are able to shut up all doubters.
The better question is, do first week sales even matter for TWICE when they are gonna outsell every GG on this list except for 1 or 2 at best?
4th gen groups can have this record cause they have nothing else to brag about
True, in total sales by a single album, they will probably show they are the #3 girl group in Kpop.
Like I said first week sales have never been their strength so this would just be more of the same, not really indicative of anything. First month or so sales will give a more accurate picture of where they stand among ggs now 
btw.
btw.
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Red Velvet with over a million, that is impressive.
This is all album sales right, not just the most recent album.
Like I said first week sales have never been their strength so this would just be more of the same, not really indicative of anything. First month or so sales will give a more accurate picture of where they stand among ggs now
For total, they could finish #3 for sure (after September).
If Once do support them, they may even get close to Aespa and hold the #2 spot for a few days, until Black Pink releases their Album.
Red Velvet with over a million, that is impressive.
This is all album sales right, not just the most recent album.
Up to last gaon update I think
Red Velvet with over a million, that is impressive.
This is all album sales right, not just the most recent album.
That is impressive considering they were only selling under 200K per comeback for the longest time. Kpop album inflation makes the global inflation look like child's play.
Kinda confused at people saying first week sales were never their strength when not even 3 years ago they were breaking the first day/first week GG album sales record every other month along with IZ*ONE
I think they'll do well the fact that this is one of their longest hiatuses between comebacks will surely drive up the sales
Kinda confused at people saying first week sales were never their strength when not even 3 years ago they were breaking the first day/first week GG album sales record every other month along with IZ*ONE
I think they'll do well the fact that this is one of their longest hiatuses between comebacks will surely drive up the sales
They had a comeback in November and this is their longest hiatus?
Dang Twice puts out more Albums than I take shits.
Hard working group for sure. JYP is milking once for all they got.
Display MoreThey had a comeback in November and this is their longest hiatus?
Dang Twice puts out more Albums than I take shits.
Hard working group for sure. JYP is milking once for all they got.
yeah...they used to do like 6 comebacks a year alternating between Korean and Japanese releases.
maybe it's a Chinese fanbase existence problem idk
maybe it's a Chinese fanbase existence problem idk
Maybe JYP should make digital albums available in China
But Itzy did well with out them, Twice should be able to at least outsell their sister act.
Obviously Twice (anyone) will not be able to compete vs BlackPink in China.
Display MoreMaybe JYP should make digital albums available in China
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
But Itzy did well with out them, Twice should be able to at least outsell their sister act.
That wasn't what I was talking about, I'm talking fanbase. It's really small
1) they killed their chances early on, we know how
2) their concept isn't for China. I believe I remember Cry For Me outcharting any of their other songs
Anything is possible
That wasn't what I was talking about, I'm talking fanbase. It's really small
1) they killed their chances early on, we know how
2) their concept isn't for China. I believe I remember Cry For Me outcharting any of their other songs
their concept is for china also it’s just that taiwan vs china thing it ruined everything I’m pretty sure they’ll be the top gg in china too remember tzuyu bagging celebrities admirers there and with Chinese cf
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
