I - Taeyeon vs I'm Nayeon - Nayeon: Battle of the First Mini Albums

Haven’t heard the albums but I > Pop. It’s the only taeyeon song I like actually.

I millions mile better

I love Nayeon too

but I is iconic, I still remember the day it got released, was a huge deal and the song is gorgeous!

& should add that farewell and UR are such great songs!

Interesting that both have the first person singular subjective pronoun.

I like more I'm Nayeon. I feel is an album more completed. I is nice too but not too diverse.

Quote from Daileemidzy

I is a beautiful song and I like it more than Pop!, but in terms of the albums, Nayeon pulls ahead for me. Just not a ballad girl.

that’s valid, they are both great first solo debuts

I prefer "I" Album

I rate Taeyeon's early stuff highly and My Voice is still my favourite solo album of all time in kpop, but the only good b-side on her debut mini is U R

Yes, I like Nayeon.

both

Quote from ISaidISaid

Haven’t heard the albums but I > Pop. It’s the only taeyeon song I like actually.

Surprised to hear that .. What other songs have you heard of Taeyeon's? She has a pretty versatile discography so I'm surprised you only like I

I'm Nayeon.

Love Countdown is top tier and Happy Birthday To You is high tier. But everything in I is high tier with U R being top tier and I top top tier. Easy choice for me.

I is way better than Pop in terms of pure music. Pop obviously has a great MV and choreo though, and a better bridge. Plus Taeyeon has better B sides overall, even though i think No Problem is the best B side of them all. The edge goes to Taeyeon.

Quote from spark

Surprised to hear that .. What other songs have you heard of Taeyeon's? She has a pretty versatile discography so I'm surprised you only like I

Oh no her voice is mostly not it for me personally but this song I is very similar to the English song Crush and I loved that one and in turn I liked this too.

'I' definitely has the better title track.

But when it comes to the b-sides, I think I prefer I'm Nayeon which has b-sides like All or Nothing, Candyfloss, Happy Birthday to You and Love Countdown.

I'm Nayeon has a lot of good songs but I prefer the songs on Taeyeon album more.