everyone in the main has told us that Nayeon has a better soloist career in SK, yet on Gaon:
Rosé debuted 15/49 with 2 english tracks while facing an IU comeback and a Rollin viral moment
Nayeon debuted 99 with a full promoted korean song while facing no one
Rosé peaked at 4 with over 400k uls
Nayeon peaked at 18 with less than 200k uls
I think people said that because we never know when Rose will make another solo comeback so they are maybe basing it off “potential” in the long run. I don’t agree though, Rose’s songs are more appealing to me. Rose should comeback again and see how she does cause I heard Melon is losing listeners which affects the ULs? I like Rose’s solo more and people say koreans love her voice so YG should give her more comebacks. BP is also more popular than Twice. Nayeon’s solo wasn’t anything special imo it’s like Twice 2.0 but sang by one person.
It says a lot when kpop stans use bp's mistreatment to guarantee assurance for their favs having better achievements. Sometimes I do look back and think about that one post someone made in anon a while back how ggs must feel great because bp barely gets to comeback and the attention isn't taken away from them.
the timing is different. melon's users have been decreasing over the years so we can't really compare.
Besides everything the song was 100 times better.
Pop was not it for a debut
That thread having so many people say nayeon over rosé was comedy considering how well she performed in kr and internationally. Really shows akp downplay bp
Which thread
It says a lot when kpop stans use bp's mistreatment to guarantee assurance for their favs having better achievements. Sometimes I do look back and think about that one post someone made in anon a while back how ggs must feel great because bp barely gets to comeback and the attention isn't taken away from them.
still with no come back they take all the attention anyway. Lisa made 7million twitts with LisaxCeline alone. And to compair with BP those "haters" secure that someone will read their post, cos without BP on the title people wouldn´t pay attention. Look how sm use BP to promote aespa, by compairing to BP or making remarks to piss Blinks off.
still with no come back they take all the attention anyway. Lisa made 7million twitts with LisaxCeline alone. And to compair with BP those "haters" secure that someone will read their post, cos without BP on the title people wouldn´t pay attention. Look how sm use BP to promote aespa, by compairing to BP or making remarks to piss Blinks off.
Why are u even bringing up spammed hashtagd by sopo stans and fandom? Twitter hashtags mean nothing except stans being jobless and spamming it to the core. While charting means popularity to the GP. Besides what's the correlation of Twitter hashtag to Music charting?
The downplay of rose already in here
Like TRUST me she would definitely be charting better if her song was released today. For some reason it’s only otg that wouldn’t chart as well as it did a year before according to akp
Honestly I just know if a bp member was charting like nayeon right now anon even main would be filled with WHY ARE THEY FLOPPING posts
Just shows how bp is held to another standard of success
The obvious answer is that Rose is a BP member: they're by far the most popular girl group, still, even after 2 years hiatus.
I never understood why people were underestimated Rosé in that thread
Which Nayeon charting are you guys looking at ?
She entered top 20 on melon this morning
She has the trot king who came back similiar time and has Korean ahjummas on hold
Melon users have decreased , more people are using YouTube musics. Her international charting is solid .
Nayeon is not flopping no matter how much you keep lying to yourself in fact there is a trending post on instiz talking about how great Nayeon song is moving up the charts especially in this difficult time as it’s rainy season not yet really summer with sun shining yet people are listening to the song.
Talent, charisma won.
Rosé debuted in 2021 after BP had established themselves as the biggest GG and even then her solo did average at best, 5 weeks in top 10 is nothing monumental.
Nayeon went solo after Twice released Scientist which is their biggest flop, and she's out here outdoing it and reaching new peaks everyday.
Like the comparison isn't fair at all. If both debuted in 2018/19 when Twice were at their peak and BP although popular not really the top gg, Nayeon would have destroyed Rosé on charts.
dumb dumb did a lot better
DD peaked at #8. Pop could surpass it in a week.
Nayeon's MV likes are higher than Somi's were at the same time.
Although, it is ironic that the center of one of the biggest GG ever is not doing that much better than the group's reject that hasn't been in any group for 5 years (JYP was clearly hoping to put her in his next group but it took too long).
Also shows you how difficult it is to go solo.
Let the song run it's course first. I feel it has more chance of having longevity than R on charts.
Once are the same people who ignore Scientist (unless it's to compare with Nayeon's Pop to make that look better) and who kept yelling that Alcohol-Free was doing spectacular on charts, when 10 and more girl groups were charting better.
So yeah, don't expect them to put off their rosy tinted glasses that gives every TWICE member achievement a glow up while 100% ignoring any lacklustre result, whether that's Scientist, Korean charting, popularity or streaming.
Which Nayeon charting are you guys looking at ?
She entered top 20 on melon this morning
She has the trot king who came back similiar time and has Korean ahjummas on hold
Melon users have decreased , more people are using YouTube musics. Her international charting is solid .
Nayeon is not flopping no matter how much you keep lying to yourself in fact there is a trending post on instiz talking about how great Nayeon song is moving up the charts especially in this difficult time as it’s rainy season not yet really summer with sun shining yet people are listening to the song.
Rosé also faced Lim Young Woung and she even managed to beat him on music shows, so not an excuse
It's been a few days since Nayeon debuted. How can you compare the two?
Rose didn't immediately peak at #4, it took time, and Nayeon's rising every single day.
You literally said it in the OP, she debuted at #99 on a Friday and has now risen to #18 in less then a week.
99 is on gaon which tracked 1 day, the debut for OTG with 1 day of tracking was 15
Once are the same people who ignore Scientist (unless it's to compare with Nayeon's Pop to make that look better) and who kept yelling that Alcohol-Free was doing spectacular on charts, when 10 and more girl groups were charting better.
So yeah, don't expect them to put off their rosy tinted glasses that gives every TWICE member achievement a glow up while 100% ignoring any lacklustre result, whether that's Scientist, Korean charting, popularity or streaming.
Agree with this,
but lol, the excuses from onces are hilarious. 
as a blink this makes the most sense out of all the comments i read on here. as much as we hate yg, they do a great job at promoting the girls individually. but if you’re into group activities then you won’t like it. jyp should have debuted her solo when twice were at their peak but they focused more on group activities as it obviously brought more money to them and it’s easier to manage twice in a group rather than individual activities since there are a lot of members in twice.
It's been a few days since Nayeon debuted. How can you compare the two?
Rose didn't immediately peak at #4, it took time, and Nayeon's rising every single day.
You literally said it in the OP, she debuted at #99 on a Friday and has now risen to #18 in less then a week.
Actually rosé peaked within the first few days...
Lmao Nayeon is a better dancer, singer, and more charismatic than Rosé.
In what universe are you talking about 
In what universe are you talking about
It’s true that she’s a better singer technique wise , dance could be subjective, I think Nayeon dancing is very pretty , I can’t explain it . Both have charisma in their groups concept so there is no need for comparison . Both solos showed they can handle the stage
The delusions 🤭
You stan Twice please, you survive of their visuals.
And BP or any BP solo can come back any time that they will still surpass any Twice or Twice solos numbers. It won't make a difference. And I'm talking about the present ok? Not 2016 numbers..
I'm gonna co-sign this one. And I fucks with Rosè. Rosè is a great singer and puts on a show, but if you were to put both her and Nayeon together, I'm gonna be looking at Nayeon the whole time. Rosè is a little too perfect and that makes her a bit boring to watch. Also comes off a little try-hard (no offense to her). But Nayeon is naturally charismatic and knows how to draw your eyes to her. And this is probably just personal taste, but I also think Nayeon's voice is better than Rosè. So i can actually listen to more than one song in a row by Nayeon, whereas with Rosè, im not sure. Rose's voice is a lot sometimes.
Also, I wish ppl will stop staying how Jyp lost the hype for Nayeon and how she should've debuted a long time ago.
I feel like ppl are literally forgetting covid changed a whole lot of plans for a whole lot of companies. I think Nayeon herself said they had this song for a while. I wouldnt be surprised if she was scheduled to debut years ago, but covid fucked up the plan. And i cant blame Jyp for that. It would've been crazy to debut Nayeon during Covid without the loud audience cheers and in person fan meetings. You dont debut as a solo in those conditions. Jyp was smart to wait and now Pop/Nayeon are smashing and Nayeon's getting a second wind of popularity.
Also, im sure Pop is going to have a big impact with all these challenges and the summer about to start. Nayeon's already doing stellar international numbers and smashing in Korea is gonna be the cherry on the sundae.
People are way too early/hyped to try and downplay Twice here.
Rosé better singer dancer and better stage presence, she actually knows how to hype a crowd
Nayeon is the better dancer and has better stage presence but Rose is a better singer.
as a blink this makes the most sense out of all the comments i read on here. as much as we hate yg, they do a great job at promoting the girls individually. but if you’re into group activities then you won’t like it. jyp should have debuted her solo when twice were at their peak but they focused more on group activities as it obviously brought more money to them and it’s easier to manage twice in a group rather than individual activities since there are a lot of members in twice.
What yg did is going to help the members in long run. Twice would have to stick with the jyp because of "twice" brand meanwhile BP has established themselves as soloist, they can leave anytime. I'm not a BP fan but I think yg did a good job in this aspect.
nope they are about the same level in technique but Rosé is a musician so skills wise Rosé has the whole package and no one can deny Rosé's charisma
People talking shit here, Rosé is a better vocalist, both are under the average level but Rosé has better support. And she still more succesful, so stop underestimate her
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
