? 102
-
Yes, aespa have surpassed twice (7) 7%
-
No they haven’t (95) 93%
Let’s bring this discussion to main forum why y’all fighting on anons..comment from main lol
Let’s bring this discussion to main forum why y’all fighting on anons..comment from main lol
For me no they haven’t.
And no it’s not album sales or #1 hits. These metrics all fall second to the main thing : touring.
Twice never had China so imo multiple future groups are gonna overtake them in sales looking at how 4th gen have started selling. Those millions are gonna come quick.
But for me this is actually quite an irrelevant point in front of their touring ability. Bro unless you sell out Tokyo dome multiple dates like twice do or do what they did in NA… you can’t even be mentioned in the same sentence as them take several seats.
Overall career it's not even close. Twice was much bigger in sk at aespa's age
Twice are bigger not because of their Korean digital domination or relevance. For me a big 3 GG having Korean hits is actually not enough for the conversation about being a top group. In all likelihood this is the metrics that’s going to be easiest for a hit gg to catch up to.
So it’s no use bringing that up and that actually leaves ppl to downplay twice. Even if aespa or ive or whomever even if they have multiple back to back hits unless they can fill those stadiums, it doesn’t really actually matter.
i don't think so. I can't give you stats, numbers, or something like that to prove it but it's just my feeling they haven't (does that make sense? )
Korean digitals, yes. Everything else, not yet.
But make no mistake, the Third Age of Kpop is ending, it's only a matter of time. The last Lion Kings just went down the past couple weeks, the final nail in the coffin.
The last holdouts, the last warhorses of the Third Age, are probably gonna rally over the next year or two to make one last defiant stand. Not as a combined Army, no, they're sending out their individual champions one by one this time. Seulgi, Jhope, and the one most relevant here...Nayeon. If she can outchart Aespa by herself...
Twice are bigger not because of their Korean digital domination or relevance. For me a big 3 GG having Korean hits is actually not enough for the conversation about being a top group. In all likelihood this is the metrics that’s going to be easiest for a hit gg to catch up to.
So it’s no use bringing that up and that actually leaves ppl to downplay twice. Even if aespa or ive or whomever even if they have multiple back to back hits unless they can fill those stadiums, it doesn’t really actually matter.
If it's about touring why are you even comparing the two groups? Twice has a very successful tour this year itself while aespa won't tour and it'll come no where close to current Twice or maybe even when twice was younger
Twice did rise to stardom through cheer up becoming massive in sk? And no not all ggs reach that level in sk even if they are from big3. Also twice is big in Japan, songs, album sales and tours. Even on international streaming much bigger so the comparison is off.
If it's about touring why are you even comparing the two groups? Twice has a very successful tour this year itself while aespa won't tour and it'll come no where close to current Twice or maybe even when twice was younger
Twice did rise to stardom through cheer up becoming massive in sk? And no not all ggs reach that level in sk even if they are from big3. Also twice is big in Japan, songs, album sales and tours.
I know that’s why I said twice are much higher and can’t be compared yet Kek.
everyone can see aespa has surpassed twice in korea and china. But other countries where they have been surpassed to others' surprise are thailand and indonesia. So it's really even right now for me because aespa has captured all the important markets in kpop.
Korea always likes the newer trendy GG. Even aespa will be overtaken there tomorrow kekeke.
But markets like NA and Japan that’s where the eyes are when it comes to tours. China is good for album sales but it doesn’t allow for touring so it’s not as viable an option as the others.
Korea always likes the newer trendy GG. Even aespa will be overtaken there tomorrow kekeke.
But markets like NA and Japan that’s where the eyes are when it comes to tours. China is good for album sales but it doesn’t allow for touring so it’s not as viable an option as the others.
I thought you were asking about popularity . No disrespect to twice but they are an old group who had enough time to gain fanbase to tour in NA. Aespa needs more time in america. As for japan, it's the same but japan is twice's country and aespa needs more time there as well.
Twice always #1 in my heart
No they haven't. The only girlgroup who is a competitor to Twice is Blackpink and that didn't change. Twice has a legacy which isn't easy to put down. Years of popularity, years of being the top girlgroup and a girlgroup which debuted 2020 with only few releases should change that? no way. Aespa is great and I love them so much but let's be realistic. You can't surpass a group with millions of records in two years. No way.
I don't like these threads. It is unfair to aespa who don't have anywhere near the time Twice had to show their full potential, and almost a insult to Twice, who spent years building what they have now.
Popularity is so arbitrary. You are not really popular if you can’t tour well end of.
Exactly, in fact I cant name a time when Ive seen any genuine MYs here say this or come at Twice. it's mostly just Twice antis.
In fact the only person who voted 'Yes' is a famous Twice hater and not a Aespa fan at all. A person that used to cosplay as a Once in the past. These are the type of users making the threads in anon I'm convinced, not actual Aespa stans.
This.
Btw I’m not saying aespa won’t ever be able to do this…. But imo these discussions without a sizable tour is quite insulting to twice.
EXO is only group (aside from maybe produce groups) who had huge tours in their 2nd year
We will see how well AESPA will do once they start touring, their Japanese showcase had 400k pre applications which is crazy.
What AESPA is missing but Twice has is 7 years of successful career and bigger legacy
simple answer: no
long answer: what are the criteria one is using in order to judge whether one group has "surpassed" another
ie the metrics and the weighting of such metrics
just one example would be lets say Korean Charting - are we looking at total goan numbers? goan numbers/no. of songs? twice @ year [x] vs. aespa @ year [x] etc etc
long answer: what are the criteria one is using in order to judge whether one group has "surpassed" another
ie the metrics and the weighting of such metrics
"What have you done for me lately" recency bias
"What have you done for me lately" recency bias
I make a similar point everytime there's a [group A] vs [group B] thread or whose songs is bigger/better etc etc
People who only comment these things in anon but say nothing in main are lil bitches. Be transparent
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!